Investigation reveals systemic failures and unauthorized construction at Queen Mary Hospital
An investigation report submitted to the Legislative Council on November 11, 2026, reveals systemic failures and unauthorized construction within the new Clinical Building 1 at Queen Mary Hospital. The report details 238 lift failures that occurred between September 2025 and January 2026, within five months of the building being handed over to the Hospital Authority. These incidents included 18 cases where people were trapped inside the lifts.
Structural and construction violations
The investigation identified significant unauthorized construction work performed by the contractor, On Bo Construction. Between May and December 2024, the Buildings Department discovered unauthorized concrete chipping in eight different locations. These violations were located across two lift shafts, three lift machine rooms, and four lift landing doors. Rather than rectifying the chipping, the contractor performed additional unauthorized chipping to address issues within the shafts.
Structural deviations were also documented in the 32-story building. Four lift shafts, specifically L3, L10, L15, and L18, exhibited deviations in dimensions and verticality ranging from 62 mm to 82 mm. These shafts also sustained significant damage to reinforcement steel due to the unauthorized chipping. Furthermore, the lift subcontractor, On Lee, installed guide rails and cabins that failed to meet design specifications. This included the irregular cutting of guide rail brackets to accommodate deviations found within the shafts.
Lift machinery and safety issues
The report highlights extensive technical problems with the building's vertical transport systems. A total of 28 lifts were identified as having engineering problems. Of the 238 recorded failures, 100 were related to lift machinery, including issues involving circuit boards and compensator cable tensioner safety switches. The investigation also noted that 25 lifts had safety certificates signed by a suspended engineer.
The failures in the building's infrastructure led to significant public concern and media scrutiny. Legislator Chen Kai-yan criticized the poor workmanship of the contractor and noted the failure of various departments to detect these issues during the inspection process. The investigation was prompted by public concern regarding lift safety and the frequency of breakdowns following the building's phased operation, which began in November 2025.
Institutional responses and oversight
The Development Bureau has faced scrutiny regarding the transparency of the investigation. In March and April 2026, the Development Bureau refused a request from the Health Bureau to proactively disclose the lift issues to the public. This lack of disclosure occurred despite the ongoing operational status of the Clinical Building 1.
The scale of the project underscores the gravity of the construction failures. The contract value for the main works of the new building was 9.45 billion HKD. The investigation into the systemic failures and unauthorized modifications remains a central focus for the Legislative Council and relevant government departments.
Glossary
- Legislative Council — The Legislative Council is a body whose members can be elected by the Election Committee. It is a legislative institution that receives investigation reports and is a focus for oversight regarding systemic failures.
- Hospital Authority — The Hospital Authority is an organization that manages public hospitals. It provides management for facilities such as the Alice Ho Miu Ling Nethersole Hospital.
- Queen Mary Hospital — Queen Mary Hospital is a healthcare facility. It is part of an overhaul of the healthcare system involving several hospitals.
This article was written with AI assistance from multiple news reports and is reviewed by our editors under our editorial principles. Editorial Standards · Tips & Contact
Comments 0